OUR STORY

BEST SLICE IN TOWN!

ORDER ONLINE

THE P.JAY'S PIZZA STORY

Mario and Angelina Mastroianni instilled in their sons a love of everything Italian—the country, the people, the traditions and the food.


A shoemaker by trade, Mario understood the importance of quality materials and fine craftsmanship. So when he made Sunday dinner for his family, he used only the best ingredients, cooked fresh and carefully prepared. His spaghetti and meatballs are a family legend. And Angelina, a homemaker renowned for her freshly baked bread, insisted that food served at her table be made from scratch— with love—the Old World way. 

THE MASTROIANNI

FAMILY TRADITION LIVES ON

When their son Chris Mastroianni opened his first pizza shop in 1974, his parents told him, “Use only the best ingredients, prepared fresh.” In fact, he not only took their advice, he hired them both!


Starting with his father's homemade tomato sauce recipe and his mother's made-from-scratch pizza dough, Chris used only the finest quality meats, vegetables and cheese to create an especially flavorful pizza with a uniquely satisfying taste. Under the watchful eyes of his parents, that was the beginning of P.Jay's Pizza.


In 2018, another family-owned business took over ownership of this storied pizzeria and continues the traditions of the Mastroianni family.

440-885-4355

FAQS

  • What size pizzas do you offer?
    • Small 9 inch — 6 pieces
    • Large 12 inch — 8 pieces
    • Jumbo 16 inch — 12 pieces
    • Half Sheet — square-cut 15 or 20 pieces
    • Full Sheet — square-cut 30 or 40 pieces

  • Can I pre-order?

    Yes, you can call us or order online up to 30 days in advance.

  • Do you offer catering?

    Yes. We have a catering menu to suit all of your group gathering needs. More information can be found on our website or by calling us.

  • Do you offer specials or coupons?

    Yes! Keep up to date with weekly deals and promotions by joining our loyalty program or following our Facebook page. Current coupons can be found on our website.

  • Do you have on-site parking or curbside pickup?

    Yes, parking is available behind the building off of Wilbur Road.


    Curbside is also behind the building, so please let us know at the time of order you would like to pick up curbside & check in when you arrive by clicking the link in your confirmation text or by calling us at (440) 885-4355.